Wiley: UW budget cuts ‘careless stupidity’

Wiley: UW budget cuts ‘careless stupidity’
John Wiley

I am frequently approached by people, whether friends and acquaintances, or total strangers, who want to ask about or complain about something involving the university. My usual response is: “I’m retired. That’s someone else’s problem now.”

But that is a flippant response, and only partly true. Yes, I am retired. No, it’s not just someone else’s problem. Everything that affects the university affects us all, and should be of concern to every Wisconsin citizen. This state has invested a great deal in the university since its very founding, and has a lot at stake in preserving that investment.

At 5.8 million population, Wisconsin is a middle-sized state (1.8 percent of the US population; 20th out of the 50 states; somewhat below average in per capita income). Having lived in New Jersey for seven years, I can tell you that most Easterners can’t find Wisconsin on the map. In fact, there are only three things they know about Wisconsin: cheese, home of the Green Bay Packers, and the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Those things they know and admire, probably more than most Wisconsin natives.

In 1900, Wisconsin was one of only 14 research universities that came together to form the now prestigious Association of American Universities (AAU – now 62 universities, including all the well-known household name schools).

The purpose of forming the AAU was to secure for America a deserved place among the older and better-established European universities such as Oxford, Cambridge, Heidelberg, Zurich, and others. Of the 14 founding members, 11 were private, mostly Ivy League, schools. Only three were public schools: Michigan, California (now UC-Berkeley), and Wisconsin (now UW-Madison).

The AAU has succeeded to the point where AAU schools totally dominate world university rankings.

How did little Wisconsin end up in such elite company? How has Wisconsin stayed there for 115 years? Unless you can answer those two questions convincingly, you had better be very, VERY careful about tinkering with the details of an organization you don’t understand, and one that has been and is critical to the past, present, and future of Wisconsin.

The latest huge budget cut (the fifth in the last six biennia), together with extraordinarily ill-conceived changes in our governance structure, may well mark the start of an irrecoverable decline. It’s much easier to remain on top than it is to climb back after sliding down a steep hill. And the hill is steep, indeed.

There are now more than 4,000 degree-granting universities in the US, almost all of which aspire to displace UW-Madison. Wisconsin has been easily in the top 14 of those 4,000 schools by any measure for 115 years – often in the top two-to-three among ALL US universities. Where would you like us to be? Number 100, 500, 2,000, 4,000?

Just follow the Walker path if that’s what you want. And if you do follow Walker, that’s what you’ll get. It’s easy. It’s mindless. It takes no thought, understanding, money, or effort at all: just careless stupidity. The rest of the 50 states will applaud if Wisconsin takes itself out of the competition.

In the meantime, Wisconsin will deserve what it voted for and what it ends up with, and Walker can take his run at ruining the entire country instead of a middle-sized, Midwestern state that, until now, has punched way above its weight class and has put little Wisconsin on the world map.

John Wiley is UW-Madison Chancellor Emeritus